What to Look for in a Marketing Partner (8 Key Characteristics)

How do you know if a marketing agency is any good? And, perhaps even more importantly, how do you know if they’re good for your business?

These are the kinds of questions that can keep a business owner or internal marketing lead up at night. Choosing the right marketing company is a high-stakes decision. Fortunately, you can look for a few things during the evaluation process to make a more informed, confident decision.

Here are the traits worth digging into when evaluating your next marketing partner.

Here are eight key characteristics of a strong marketing partner:

A strong track record
A team with the right expertise
A combination of strategy and tactics
Credentials and distinctions that matter
A personality and culture fit
Transparent reporting and expert analysis
Transparent pricing and alignment with your budget
The right technology to support your goals

The right marketing partner will learn your unique business and help you grow through all the marketing channels that matter. Here are the attributes you should consider when choosing yours.

🚀Great marketing starts with a plan. Download How to Create a Small Business Marketing Plan (The Complete Guide +Template!) >>

1. A strong track record

The first thing to look for in a marketing partner or agency is a history of good work and great results. A marketing partner should have a portfolio that showcases work similar to what you’re looking to create for your business.

Whether that’s a new website design, a blog, a PPC ad campaign, or something else, look for actual pieces or case studies on their site that show they’ve done something akin to what you want.

Read a few case studies from businesses similar to yours.

Beyond looking sleek, the best marketing agencies can explain the impact their work had for clients. Was there a strong marketing ROI on the campaign? Did the email newsletter drive meaningful revenue growth? Look for numbers that show the work created a measurable outcome.

2. A team with the right expertise

Many marketing partners have teams with decades of combined experience and lots of creative work under their belts. When looking for the right marketing agency or partner, remember to look beyond the general track record for specific experience in the area that matters to you.

If you work in a regulated industry, like healthcare or financial services, make sure the team has direct experience in your field.

A partner can also support the specific channels that matter to you. Say you need help managing your social media; you’ll want to find a team with social media experience that has helped businesses in your industry and geography.

Look at the marketing output, like social media posts, from the partner’s other clients.

Also consider how much historical data they have from previous campaigns. A local business without years of advertising history won’t have the data modern ad platforms need to dial in bidding and tracking. The right marketing partner will bring data from previous similar businesses to help.

👍 Social media marketing doesn’t have to be hard. Get The Definitive Guide to Social Media Marketing (Simplified!)

3. A combination of strategy and tactics

You’ll never see a strong marketing ROI if you don’t tie your daily marketing actions to a broader strategy. When evaluating prospective marketing companies, it’s important to look beyond the tactics they support—PPC advertising, social media management, and the like—and to get a sense of whether they connect their tactical work to your business objectives.

Marketing tactics can’t move the needle for your business if they’re disconnected from your goals. The best marketing agencies know that and will work with you to define your objectives and create a marketing plan that aligns marketing decisions with your big-picture targets.

4. Credentials and distinctions that matter

With your marketing goals in mind, look for an agency with credentials and certifications that help your brand achieve them.

For example, if you’re looking for an agency to handle your PPC or social media, you might want an official Google and Meta advertising partner. Or, if you want an SEO agency partner, check that team members have certifications from trusted names in the space.

Those badges aren’t just decoration. They indicate industry partnerships and expertise that can benefit your business.

If you see a lot of badges on a prospective marketing partner’s website, it’s worth Googling to see what each one means and how that credential or award might help them deliver better work for you.

5. A personality and culture fit

This quality isn’t as quantifiable as some others, but that doesn’t make it any less important. It comes down to a fundamental question: Do I want to work with this marketing company?

If you’re struggling to assess your options based on that broader question, you might use these more nuanced ones to get your answer:

Do I like the people I’ve met so far?
Are they clear, kind, and responsive?
Have they shared how the agency collaborates with clients, and does that working style jibe with ours?
Are they flexible or rigid in the way they approach engagements?
Are they open and warm when I ask a probing question, or defensive and evasive?
What are their stated company values, and have I seen those shine through in interactions with team members?

It’s also worth clarifying if the people you meet during sales calls are the ones who’ll be handling your account day-to-day. If not, ask to connect with your regular point of contact so you can get to know them before signing on.

6. Transparent reporting and expert analysis

When you engage a marketing partner, you’re not only looking for creative output. You also want someone tracking the marketing metrics to show what’s working. You want a partner with the experience to put the data in context and use it to inform future actions. Ideally, you’d want results available anytime in a dashboard, not only at scheduled check-ins.

Ready access to success metrics across the entire marketing funnel is a key indicator of a great marketing partner.

When assessing partners, ask them how they handle reporting. What is the typical cadence, what KPIs get shared, and do they provide commentary around the numbers to help you understand what they actually mean?

7. Transparency on pricing and alignment with your budget

You don’t need a multimillion-dollar budget to work with a marketing partner. But your budget will partly dictate what services they provide.

The key is finding a marketing company that is a good match for your marketing budget. Be honest from the start about what you’re able to spend so the provider can give a realistic overview of what it can provide.

Set your budget before contacting potential partners so you can quickly see which one is right for you.

As you review proposals, look for language that clarifies what’s in scope, what’s not, and how the agency handles things like overages. Also review clauses that stipulate contract length; some agencies will want you to agree to a set timeframe for retainer-based work, since it can take months to see measurable results in ongoing marketing.

8. The right technology to support your goals

Great digital marketing blends human experience with technology. So a marketing partner should provide both people and platforms to create, optimize, and track your promotional strategies.

While tech shouldn’t replace people, you can ask if a potential partner uses it to help you:

Optimize your ad spend across marketing channels
Manage and prioritize incoming leads
Track and summarize customer communications
Report on metrics with clear visuals and insights
Target ads using historical data

See if your potential marketing partner has technology that helps you scale your business efficiently.

Finding the perfect marketing partner

A marketing agency out there is a perfect fit for your business and needs; it just takes a little legwork to find it.

By assessing options on key attributes like past work, areas of expertise, and credentials, you can build a shortlist. Then, as you meet with prospective providers, talk with the team, learn how they work, and clarify your budget to refine your perspective and find the best-fit agency.

When you’re in the market for a new partner, reach out. We’ll show you how our expert team, extensive campaign data, and proprietary tools have helped businesses like yours grow.

Meet The Author

Amanda Rodhe

Amanda Rodhe is a freelance content marketing writer. She’s passionate about the power of the written word and loves helping brands craft compelling stories that stick. You can connect with her on LinkedIn or learn more at www.amandarodhe.com.